This is the set list for Episode 657: Good Luck Has Its Storms which originally aired on May 14, 2025 and can be heard here.
- Ye Banished Privateers: Welcome To Tortuga; Songs and Curses
- Ship Shape: The Wellerman; She Shanties
- The Penniless Jacks: Rollin’ Down to Old Maui; Three Pennies Short
- The Crimson Pirates: Northwest Passage; Sail On
- Below the Gaff: Leaving of Liverpool; The Cape Horn Star
- Capt’n Tor & the Naer-Do-Well Cads Pirate Invasion: Dennis Murphy & John Ryan’s Polka Medley; Fanny
- The Longest Johns: South Australia; Uncharted – Pieces of Eight – Single
- Under The Black Pirate Troupe: All for Me Grog; Down for Boat Stuff, Vol. 1
- All For Jolly: Spanish Galleon (ft. Aubrey Blakeledge); All For Jolly – Second Album
- Ye Banished Privateers: Whydah Galley; ‘Til the Sea Shall Give up Her Dead
- Nordanfolk (Norðanfólk): Þat mælti mín móðir; Blood Harmony
- Valkyrik: Hasten; Valkyrik EP
- Tordenkor: Berserker; Tordenkor – EP
- The Dread Crew Of Oddwood: Leviathan; Rocktopus
- Maelstr’m: Maelstr’m
- Celtic Conundrum: Mostly Druid; Lore
- Pride of Bedlam: Sloop John B; Cheat Death
- Music The Gathering: Tom of Bedlam; LVL 3
- The Pirates Charles: One Mo’ Bottle O’ Rum; Rise
- Stormfrun: Drink Up Your Rum; Pirate For The Rum
- Wakefire: Johnny Jump Up; Meaning of Life
- Tom Mason and the Blue Buccaneers: If You Want to Be a Pirate; If You Want to Be a Pirate: Songs for Young Buccaneers
- Pyrates!: High Barbary (Live); Five Years at Sea
- Durty Rotten Parrots: Walk The Plank; Requirments 2B A Pirate
- The Bilge Pumps: Yo Ho; Planned Piratehood
- Alestorm: Keelhauled; Black Sails At Midnight
- Musical Blades: No Time Like Today; Modern Day Pirate
- Pat Razket: Far from Home; Hymns from the Abyss
- The Dreadnoughts: Mary the One Eyed Prostitute Who Fought the Colossal Squid and S; Legends Never Die
- Dandy Highwaymen: The Periwig; Land Shanties
- RustMonster: Still A’smilin’; Last Voyage of the Black Betty
- Pride of Bedlam: Heave Away; Boarding Party
